Alex who worked on my house used natural milk paint pigments from Homestead House to stain the poplar floors and stairs in my tiny house.
These pigments were extremely difficult to work with and I did not end up liking the result. But I have a few tips on how to get a better result.
This post contains affiliate links. Upon purchase, I earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
The first tip is you can not go too many shades darker with these pigments. You can go one or two shades darker at most. Here you can see what happened when we stained the very light popular floor dark brown. It turned out very patchy and uneven. (Partly this was due to a softwood and the way poplar absorbs things, but I think it would come out uneven on any type of wood).
We had to go back over the floors and sand part of it off. Then go in by hand and sand the darker bits. It still isn’t where I want it to be.
The stairs went a little better as we did not attempt to go too dark there:
Applying the stain is also a difficult procedure. If you just paint it on with a paintbrush or with a cloth it will go on even more blotchy than this, and you will see all the brush lines. or lines from the cloth, because it dries in a few seconds.
Here’s how to apply it:
1. Tape off the wood along the seams in 3 or 4-inch sections length-wise. Do not tape it off width-wise or you will have a dark looking seam there.
2. Continually mix the stain/water solution so that you get a consistent amount on the brush. (2 or 3 people are needed)
3. One person paints on the stain with a brush and keeps moving down the length without stopping because it dries in a few seconds and you will have marks of where you stop if you stop. Overlapping the stain will also leave a noticeable splotch.
4. The second person follows, rubs in the stain/removes the excess with a cloth to even it out.
This has to all be done very fast.
A Note on Sealing
On top of the stain, we put hemp oil. The picture on the right is grime from the landing floor. This is just hemp oil with no stain. It does wipe off with a cloth.
If you just want a slightly enriched look I still like hemp oil as a top choice. But if you want to stain the floor a different color I would not use these pigments.
There are so many better options for wood stains that are easy to source since 2014 when I did these floors. Here is my post on stains and sealers.